Jurors Find Rutherford "Not Guilty" in Abused Child's Death - WRCBtv.com | Chattanooga News, Weather & Sports

Jurors Find Rutherford "Not Guilty" in Abused Child's Death

Reported by Mark Bruce
Eyewitness News Reporter/Anchor

CHATTANOOGA (WRCB)  In about two hours, jurors returned Not Guilty verdicts in favor of Brian Rutherford.  Rutherford mouthed the words 'thank you' to jurors after they acquitted him of Felony Murder and Aggravated Child Abuse in the 2006 death of 18 month old Sierra Carpenter.

Traci Carpenter and her family openly wept as the verdict against her former boyfriend was read.  Outside the courtroom Carpenter screamed "they let a murderer get away."

Rutherford's family felt much differently.  Brian's father said justice was done and thanked jurors for their decision.

"My son's always told the truth," said Rick Rutherford.  "It's over for us but I'm sorry it's just beginning for the other side.  We can put this behind us."

Defense attorneys believe the case was weak from the start.  They said detectives bundled the investigation and that Rutherford shouldn't have faced charges in the first place.

"This should have never been a witch hunt," said Attorney Myrlene Marsa.  "This should have been the search for the truth.  The truth came out and we're happy."

Prosecutors admit the case was a difficult one as are most cases of violence against a child.  But the State still believes they pursued the right person.

"These cases are important and even if proof isn't there, you have to try them," said Assistant District Attorney Leslie Longshore.  "I wouldn't try someone that I didn't think did it."

Traci Carpenter is due in court next month.  She faces one count of aggravated child neglect.  Prosecutors said they likely won't upgrade her charges.

  • NewsMore>>

  • Hamilton County EMS searching for person in Pocket Wilderness

    Hamilton County EMS searching for person in Pocket Wilderness

    Saturday, August 23 2014 12:51 PM EDT2014-08-23 16:51:30 GMT
    COUNTY - HamiltonCOUNTY - Hamilton
    Hamilton County EMS Crews are searching for one individual in the Pocket Wilderness.More
    Hamilton County EMS Crews are searching for one individual in the Pocket Wilderness.More
  • FDA finalizes new hydrocodone regulations

    FDA finalizes new hydrocodone regulations

    Saturday, August 23 2014 12:18 PM EDT2014-08-23 16:18:27 GMT
    The Drug Enforcement Administration said prescription drugs take the lives of more than 20,000 Americans every year.More
    The Drug Enforcement Administration said prescription drugs take the lives of more than 20,000 Americans every year.More
  • Supt. Rick Smith gets above average report card from School Board

    Supt. Rick Smith gets above average report card from School Board

    Saturday, August 23 2014 12:11 PM EDT2014-08-23 16:11:44 GMT
    Rick SmithRick Smith
    For the third straight year, Hamilton County School Board members have given their Superintendent an "above average" report card. According to scores released by Board Chairman Mike Evatt, Smith ranks highly for his choice of attire, his personal ethics, and communicating with his staff and the public. At the lower end of the scale, Board members said Smith needs to improve on keeping them informed of personnel moves, clarifying his goals, and negotiating contract details with teachers. On a ...More
    For the third straight year, Hamilton County School Board members have given their Superintendent an "above average" report card. According to scores released by Board Chairman Mike Evatt, Smith ranks highly for his choice of attire, his personal ethics, and communicating with his staff and the public. At the lower end of the scale, Board members said Smith needs to improve on keeping them informed of personnel moves, clarifying his goals, and negotiating contract details with teachers. On a ...More
Powered by WorldNow
Can't find what you're looking for?

WRCB-TV
900 Whitehall Road
Chattanooga, TN 37405
(423) 267-5412

WRCB Jobs EEO | FCC Public Files

Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WRCB. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.